Inherited Minerals

Sold inherited mineral rights? Here’s your basis

If you inherited minerals and later sold them, your gain is measured from what they were worth on the date of death. A retrospective appraisal documents that number, even years after the sale.

Your basis is the date-of-death value

Under federal tax law (IRC Section 1014), property you inherit generally takes a basis equal to its fair market value on the date of death. Not what your parents or grandparents paid for it. Not zero. And not the price you sold it for.

When you sell, your taxable gain is the sale price minus that basis. Inherited property also counts as held long term, however soon you sold it, so the gain is taxed at long-term capital gains rates.

For most heirs that is good news. A documented date-of-death value can remove most of the gain. See how stepped-up basis works for mineral rights for a worked example.

Why the sale price doesn’t settle it

Your basis is what a buyer would have paid on the date of death, using only what was known that day. Your sale happened later. In between, prices moved, wells were drilled, and production rose or fell.

If you sold within a year or two of the date of death, the two numbers are often close. If you sold five or ten years later, they can be far apart, in either direction. Either way, the sale price is evidence, not the answer.

What happens without a documented basis

When you report the sale, you list the sale price and your basis. If the IRS questions the basis, it’s on you to support it. A written appraisal as of the date of death is that support. Without one, you are left defending a number you can’t show your work on.

How a retrospective appraisal works

I value the interest as it stood on the date of death: the wells that were producing, the drilling that was planned, the prices buyers were using, and the sales happening at the time. Later events don’t change the value, though your own sale is useful market evidence. More on retrospective appraisals.

What I need from you

That’s enough to start. I pull well, permit and production data from state records myself, so you don’t have to.

One report for the whole family

When siblings inherit together, one report can value the whole interest and state each heir’s share. Each of you can rely on it for your own return. One point of contact handles communication with me, which keeps it simple for everyone.

What it costs

Most retrospective appraisals cost $5,000 to $15,000, as a fixed fee. Two things move the price the most:

Send me a check stub or division order and the date of death, and I'll give you a firm fee and delivery date. The fee is the same whatever the value comes out to.

Timing

Tell me when your return is due. I’ll give you a delivery date with the quote. If the deadline is close, ask your CPA whether an extension makes sense.

What I do, and what your CPA does

I provide the fair market value and the report behind it. Your CPA handles the return: how the sale is reported, depletion, and anything else tax-related. I’m not a CPA, and nothing here is tax advice.

Common Questions

FAQ

I already sold my inherited mineral rights. Is it too late for an appraisal?

No. A retrospective appraisal values the interest as of the date of death, whenever it is done. Many heirs order one after the sale, when the 1099 or closing statement arrives and their CPA asks for the basis.

Is my basis the price I sold for?

No. Your basis is the fair market value on the date of death. The sale price is what you received later. Your taxable gain is the difference between the two.

Do I need an appraisal if the estate filed a Form 706?

Maybe not. If the estate had to file a federal estate tax return and it reported a value for the minerals, that value generally sets your basis. Ask your CPA. If a 706 was filed, tell me and I'll tell you whether an appraisal would help before you spend anything.

How much does a retrospective mineral appraisal cost?

Most cost $5,000 to $15,000 as a fixed fee. An older date of death and more tracts or wells cost more. I quote a firm fee after seeing a check stub or division order and the date of death.

Can one appraisal cover all the heirs?

Yes. One report can value the whole interest, state each heir's share, and name each heir as someone who may rely on it.

This page is general information, not tax or legal advice. Talk to your CPA or attorney about your own situation.

Find your basis

Send the date of death and a check stub or division order. I’ll reply with a fixed-fee quote and a delivery date.

Request a Quote