Appraisals
A retrospective appraisal values your mineral and royalty interests as of a past date, usually the date of death. It’s the number your CPA needs for stepped-up basis, whether you still own the minerals or have already sold them.
The appraisal answers one question: what would a willing buyer have paid a willing seller for this interest on that day? To answer it honestly, I use only what was known, or could reasonably have been known, on that date:
What happened afterward, a new well, a price spike, or your own sale, does not change the value. A later sale can still be useful market evidence, and I take it into account where it is.
I forecast the producing wells from their history up to the effective date, then value the remaining drilling locations the way buyers did at the time, with timing and risk. Prices, costs and discount rates come from that period. I check the result against sales from the same period. The work is done in ComboCurve, the same tool used to underwrite mineral acquisitions across the U.S.
I keep the supporting workfile for at least five years, in case questions come up later.
If the estate had to file a federal estate tax return (Form 706) and reported a value for the minerals, that value generally binds the heirs’ basis. Most estates today are below the filing threshold and file no 706. In that case the appraisal sets the number. Tell me which applies, and if an appraisal won’t help you, I’ll say so before you spend anything.
Most retrospective appraisals cost $5,000 to $15,000, as a fixed fee. Two things move the price the most:
Send me a check stub or division order and the date of death, and I'll give you a firm fee and delivery date. The fee is the same whatever the value comes out to.
My fee is fixed before I start and doesn’t depend on the value. I am also EVP of Engineering at Tilden Capital, a mineral buyer, and I disclose that in every report.
I provide the fair market value and the report behind it. Your CPA or attorney decides how it is used: basis, reporting, and any filings. I’m not a CPA or an attorney, and nothing here is tax or legal advice.
Common Questions
An appraisal with an effective date in the past. For inherited minerals that date is usually the date of death, and the value becomes each heir's stepped-up basis.
Yes. Production records, historical prices and past sales are available for most U.S. basins. Older dates take more work to rebuild what was known at the time, which is one reason the fee varies.
No. The value reflects what was known on the date of death. A later sale is useful market evidence, but it is not the answer.
Most cost $5,000 to $15,000 as a fixed fee. The date of death and the number of tracts and wells have the largest effect. I quote a firm fee after seeing a check stub or division order.
The date of death and a check stub, division order, or deed. I pull well and production data from public records.
This page is general information, not tax or legal advice. Talk to your CPA or attorney about your own situation.
Send the date of death and a check stub or division order. I’ll reply with a fixed-fee quote and a delivery date.
Request a Quote